Total vote count on topic list

[crazycells]

@baris can we have another option to calculate the vote numbers of a topic in ACP? So each admin can decide for their forum. I prefer a calculation where all of the positive and negative votes in the thread are considered. Sometimes the first post may not be the key post, but rather it is a question. So it looks 0 vote, although the topic itself is very useful.

[phenomlab]

@crazycells I agree with this. I too have a number of posts on my forum where the initial didn't have many upvotes but subsequent ones do.

[baris]

Isn't this how stack overflow works as well? The vote count is for the question itself. I took a look at that code and it wasn't trivial to implement this without a new function so I added that here: https://github.com/NodeBB/NodeBB/pull/11579.

If anyone wants to build it as a plugin it can be done using the function from the above pull request. I will leave the code required here.

In plugin.json add this hook, it gets fired whenever a list of topics is loaded.

{ "hook": "filter:topics.get", "method": "filterTopicsGet" }

Now the code that will recalculate the vote count from the posts of the topics:

const db = require.main.require('./src/database');

library.filterTopicsGet = async (hookData) => {
	const voteData = await db.getSortedSetsMembersWithScores(
		hookData.topics.map(t => `tid:${t.tid}:posts:votes`)
	);
	hookData.topics.forEach((t, index) => {
		if (t) {
			const allvotes = voteData[index].reduce((acc, cur) => acc + cur.score, 0);
			t.votes += allvotes;
		}
	});
	return hookData;
};

Now the vote displayed on the topic list will be the total number of votes from all the posts in the topic.

[crazycells]

@baris thanks I hope someone with the necessary skills will step in and write the plugin for us

[crazycells]

thanks @oplik0 and @baris for the plugin...

GitHub - oplik0/nodebb-plugin-total-vote-count: Calculate vote totals based on all posts in topics and not just the inital post

Calculate vote totals based on all posts in topics and not just the inital post - GitHub - oplik0/nodebb-plugin-total-vote-count: Calculate vote totals based on all posts in topics and not just the inital post

GitHub (github.com)

[phenomlab]

@crazycells now this is definitely a plugin I'm going to use. Nobody up votes the original topic, but always the individual posts.

[crazycells]

@phenomlab yeap, we have both cases in the forum, but this calculation makes more sense to us than the first post only.

[phenomlab]

@crazycells said in Total vote count on topic list:

but this calculation makes more sense to us than the first post only.

And for me.