I'm still not clear about the discussion we had yesterday.
-
Evan Prodromoureplied to Evan Prodromou on last edited by
@steve there's no latitude at all to change the primary serialization format for AS2. JSON-LD meets all our needs, anyway.
-
Evan Prodromoureplied to Evan Prodromou on last edited by [email protected]
@steve so, I did a gist that I think represents your original point, namely, that regardless of whether the object is represented as a JSON object or an URL in the `items` property array value of an AS2 `Collection`, the triple generated to represent the relationship of containment is the same. Is that roughly it?
Converting an AS2 collection from JSON-LD to n-quads
Converting an AS2 collection from JSON-LD to n-quads - collection1a.jsonld
Gist (gist.github.com)
-
Evan Prodromoureplied to Evan Prodromou on last edited by [email protected]
@steve I can definitely agree with that, although it gets more complicated with paged collections. For AS2 and AP, this also shows a single note in a collection, but the RDF is not the same.
Paged collection
Paged collection. GitHub Gist: instantly share code, notes, and snippets.
Gist (gist.github.com)
-
@evan Yes, that’s essentially it. The AS2 Collection paging is a whole other discussion. The RDF triples are accurately representing what’s in the page-related JSON-LD, but the JSON-LD isn’t literally serializing one item in a Collection. It’s serializing a Collection referencing a CollectionPage (via `first`) that references one item (which is consistent with the RDF triples).
-
@steve the note is contained in the collection in all three examples. That's the abstract model. I agree, the RDF is different.
-
@evan Right, the RDF differs because the Collection's JSON-LD serialization is different in the paged serialization. I'd prefer that the Collection representation wouldn't change for paging, but I know that's another aspect of AS2 that will not change. Linked Data Platform (LDP) Paging describes a different way that doesn't couple the Collection and page representations so tightly. IIRC, they use Link headers for page refs and transient objects (in AP terms) for pages. https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/ldpwg/raw-file/default/ldp-paging.html
-
@steve it's neat. I can't remember why we decided not to use LDP collections.
-
-
@naturzukunft @steve if you want one, please contact O'Reilly. We're doing ebook only at first, but they said if there's enough interest they'll do a print book. So please let them know!
-
-
Question:
Hi there, i would like to order the ActivityPub by Evan Prodromou ISBN: 9781098169466 as print version. Is this possible ?Answer:
Hi Fred,
Thanks for contacting us. Unfortunately, this title has been canceled and can't be ordered. Please let me know if you have any questions.Kind regards,
Paul | Senior Customer Support -
@naturzukunft @steve Wow, what a crazy response!
