Hot take, #P2P protocols shouldn't use MDNS for peer discovery if they don't plan to use the OS provided APIs for it.
-
Hot take, #P2P protocols shouldn't use MDNS for peer discovery if they don't plan to use the OS provided APIs for it. Only one process can reliably bind the UDP port necessary for it and it quickly leads to conflicts. At the very least you should use a custom port to avoid conflicting with the OS.
-
@mauve I tend to agree. I'm working on a project that uses mDNS and after ending up with issues with certain OS's failing to work with my Go module implementation I shifted to just doing it through Avahi on the host. It's been rock solid since.
-
@jgkawell I've been leaning to just doing bespoke multicast UDP stuff personally
-
@jgkawell Is your code published somewhere I may read BTW?
-
@mauve Yes it is! Here's the relevant code but feel free to look around at the whole repo for context: https://github.com/home-cloud-io/core/blob/main/services/platform/daemon/host/mdns.go
-
Esther Payne :bisexual_flag:replied to smallcircles (Humanity Now 🕊) last edited by
@smallcircles @mauve @jgkawell Yes, well we do have some thoughts about multicast @librecast
️ -
jgkawellreplied to Esther Payne :bisexual_flag: last edited by
@onepict @smallcircles @mauve @librecast librecast looks cool! Looking at the README and it says soon there will be tunneling added to the library so it can function as an overlay network. Is there more information on that effort? I'm working on a Wireguard based overlay network to enable remote peering between home LANs so I'm curious how librecast is solving that.
