Signalling "open in app" behaviour for AP content

julian

@[email protected] thanks for the response. While I implemented the link tag for all user, post, topic, and category routes (basically, anything that had a corresponding AP endpoint), I only checked a link to a post, which should have returned a Note object.

I didn't check a link to a user profile, so maybe that's it.

AIUI, webfinger wouldn't apply for other object types.

@[email protected] @[email protected]

Mauve 👁💜

@julian @evan @silverpill Cool mind sending a link to the post json-ld and maybe the source code? I'd love to test it against my implementations and see what's up.

julian

@[email protected] Yeah, sure thing! This is the source code for one of them, it adds the link header when loading a topic.

You can try viewing the source of https://community.nodebb.org/post/99307 or making a HEAD call against it to see the meta tag and Link header, respectively.

julian

@[email protected] Also tested a user link, and that also didn't work — shrug maybe it'll work in yours?

silverpill

@julian @evan @evan Normally you send a GET request where Accept header contains the AP media type. The server checks the value of Accept header and returns either HTML page or AP object (or redirects to AP object)
I've heard about <link> tag but I don't know if any applications actually support it

Soni L.

fedilinks web+ap is probably the most widely supported, depending on how you count.

julian

Thanks @[email protected], in my case while making the call is definitely an option, I was hoping for something I could do pre-flight (e.g. an opportunistic HEAD call).

This issue provides some good guidance (with comments from @[email protected] and @[email protected] too!), so I'll have to see.

Perhaps it's just the app I'm using and it'll work fine via the web app for Mastodon.

NodeBB will implement a pre-flight HEAD call I think, although we don't yet.

silverpill

@julian @mauve @snarfed.org Content negotiation is a standard procedure described in the ActivityPub spec. Supporting other discovery methods might be a good idea (and a good topic for a FEP), but I don't recommend relying on them exclusively.

[email protected]

julian: Thanks @[email protected], in my case while making the call is definitely an option, I was hoping for something I could do pre-flight (e.g. an opportunistic HEAD call). Can you explain what you mean by this? Making a GET or HEAD request with Accept: activity+json as the highest priority and HTML as the fallback should work fine and wouldn't require any extra round trips (like a preflight or Link header would)

Evan Prodromou

@silverpill @julian @[email protected] I don't think content negotiation can be the be-all end-all. The <link> element and Link: HTTP headers are good to use. Julian, I will write it up and we'll see where it lands.

[email protected]

@evan1 I agree in theory but in this specific instance I'm not sure I understand where the Link header or meta tag would be helpful (I can definitely see where it'd be helpful for the case of e.g. a browser extension though)

julian

Thanks @[email protected] — that'd be appreciated!

@[email protected], this would be helpful in NodeBB's case where we have a web app, so rendering a link to something is just an anchor.

I could theoretically override the anchor click handler to do a backend round-trip to check whether we could load the content in-app, otherwise fall back to a regular browser behaviour (a page navigation).

For example, let's say I link out to Evan's profile here. If NodeBB knew that this link had an alternative AP endpoint, then we could redirect the user instead to the local representation of his profile

Evan Prodromou

@julian @nightpool agreed. That's positive behaviour.

a

julian: I could theoretically override the anchor click handler to do a backend round-trip to check whether we could load the content in-app, otherwise fall back to a regular browser behaviour (a page navigation). i believe this is what mastodon does, but it's also worth mentioning fep-e232 Object Links as a way to tag a given Link with the appropriate mediaType used for content negotiation: { "@context": "https://www.w3.org/ns/activitystreams", "content": "

This is an object link.

", "tag": { "type": "Link", "name": "object link", "href": "https://example.com/some-object", "mediaType": "application/ld+json; profile=\"https://www.w3.org/ns/activitystreams\"" } }

julian

@[email protected] Thanks! That's helpful (the link was purple, so I must've at least looked at it in the past...)

For those implementations using FEP-e232 I can then at least proactively update the anchor.

It's sounding more and more like I'll need to piece together multiple strategies:

Object Links if provided
On click, check with backend to see if a local representation can be navigated to
Otherwise, standard browser navigation

blaine

@evan @julian @nightpool for what it's worth, webfinger should be (re: is) able to do this, even if the implementations in the wild don't. The intent at the time was for webfinger to be the "DNS records" for "social addresses", and the main reasons we didn't just use DNS was because (1) DNS doesn't support anything but bare domain names, (2) management of DNS records at scale is hard, and (3) it wasn't possible to query DNS via the web.

blaine

@evan @julian @nightpool lots of folks advocated to support any URI scheme in a webfinger lookup, and that's why we have the "acct" scheme at all - so that email-style addresses could be used alongside http etc URIs!

The <Link> approach definitely works, but feels a bit reinventing-webfinger/creating more complexity in lookups (on the client side).

Hope the context is helpful!

Evan Prodromou

@blaine @julian @nightpool

So, for finding the AP equivalent of an URL that I think is a Web page, I'd take these steps:

- Link header: HEAD and look for the Link: header (easy, fast)
- Webfinger: Webfinger the URL (a little more complicated)
- Content negotiation: GET with Accept header set to AS2 type
- Parsing: GET and look for Link: header or <link> element

Evan Prodromou

@blaine @julian @nightpool

For finding the HTML page for an AP object:

- Link header: HEAD and look for Link:
- Content negotiation: HEAD with Accept: set to text/html
- AS2: GET and look for `url` at top level

blaine

@evan @julian @nightpool in the Postel sense, though, it's too bad that a client implementor needs to maintain (at least) four discovery pathways, and may require four separate requests to validate the information. Similarly, an ap host doesn't know which spots a client will check, so needs to implement all four. I'm well out of the standards game, but I'd very much advocate for "pick one and stick with it"