@danciruli @BlackAzizAnansi When we get a puppy, every time it wakes, eats, drinks or gets done with structured playtime, we take it outside immediately. Even short naps on the lap.We keep it compassionately crated until the first time it goes to the door by itself after it wakes, eats, or drinks.Not everyone can do this because of their schedules, etc.The downside of that, is, for the rest of its life, every time it wakes, eats or drinks it wants to go out but there is some time leeway.