In the admin control panel I can only select the initially displayed users. Once I scroll and it displays more I am completely unable to select them. For example I can select Jykliy but I am completely unable to select BananaSwag. I am running v0.5.7. Any idea why that might be?
Yes, @teh_g is correct, global moderators are special in that they will always have moderate privilege outside of the privileges page. Unfortunately it doesn't look as though you will be able to restrict gmods from their moderation privileges for this forum -- it's quite an odd use case!