[nodebb-plugin-blog-comments] Blog Commenting Engine (Ghost, Wordpress widget)

fuzzmz

Also looking into the Ghost 0.5 compatibility, but considering my knowledge of JS/NodeJS is pretty slim it might take some time. In any case, if I find anything I'll submit a pull request and update the thread here.

The problem comes mainly from the lack of an official Ghost API (well, it exists but not documented or officially released) so no bugs can be logged against it. For example, retrieving post information should be doable without having to authenticate as an admin, but right now it returns that error.

So far I've got a hackish solution to authenticating against the Ghost API and retrieving the token, but it involves hardcoded admin credentials. The next step is to pass that token as an auth header when asking for the post information.

I've got the source up on GitHub on the ghost_0.5_auth branch so any tips/info/PRs are welcome.

? Offline

@panaggio said:

Any chance hexo can get attention too?

I'd love to see this working with Hexo

fuzzmz

It looks like removing the authentication requirement for public Ghost endpoints finally appeared on their tracker (Remove authentication for public endpoints #4181), which means that at some point the comments plugin should work without any changes.

In the meantime, Ghost looks like it can be hacked to give a public route to the posts listing (haven't tested it yet - via this forum post):

Edit /ghost/core/server/routes/frontend.js
Append api = require('../api'); to the initial listing of required items.
Prepend router.get('/api/public/posts/', api.http(api.posts.browse)); to the route listing
Restart Ghost

Then the comment plugin needs to be modified so that it uses the new API route to get the post information.

psychobunny

This is exactly why I decided that I'm not going to look into this immediately I think it's an oversight on their end so I'll just wait for the dust to settle (they just released 0.5 not too long ago). Hopefully they will make those routes public, if they decide not to then I will update my plugin to authenticate

psychobunny

Haha I'm sure they have more important things to worry about at the moment. But keeping track of their progress and am liking what I see so far

fuzzmz

Hey @psychobunny, should the plugin work with v0.5.1 of NodeBB? Was currently testing with a modified version of Ghost so that I could have public API access to the posts data, but it seems that every time the comments/get/:postid/0 query hits my NodeBB instance it crashes and restarts it.

The main problem I have is that it's running on a OpenShift gear, which means that logging isn't really available (that or I can't seem to configure it properly).

fuzzmz

Ok, I managed to get the comments plugin working by hacking around Ghost and the plugin itself.

Please note though that Ghost has changed the way the JSON output of a post query is formed, so the plugin can't work (even with auth) until it gets updated to account for that. I have opened #17 - Ghost post JSON changed breaking comment publish.

The hackish workaround implies modifying both Ghost so we can have public access to the posts API and we get back the format understood by the comments plugin, as well as modifying the plugin to use the new public API URL.

Hacking Ghost
==============

In order to expose the JSON post information we need to modify two files:

/core/server/api/posts.js
/core/server/routes/frontend.js

posts.js - find the read: function read(options) { block (it should start around line 72) and duplicate it making the following changes:

change the function declaration from read: function read(options) { to readN: function readN(options) {
change the return value from return {posts: [result.toJSON()]}; to return result.toJSON();

You can see how the change looks by going here. This will return the post info in JSON format which can then be consumed by the comments plugin.

frontend.js - the following changes must be made so the new API call we wrote in posts.js gets exposed without having to authenticate.

under the utils = require('../utils'), line at the begining of the file we must add api = require('../api'),
before return router; add router.get('/api/public/posts/:id', api.http(api.posts.readN));

How the file should look can be seen here. Now going to http://your_blog/api/public/posts/1 for example will show you the post information in JSON format even without being logged to the Ghost blog.

Modifying nodebb-plugin-blog-comments
===================================

We now must modify the comments plugin to use the new API we just created at step 1.

To do this we simply edit the /public/lib/embed.js file and change adminXHR.open('GET', '/ghost/api/v0.1/posts/' + articleID); to adminXHR.open('GET', '/api/public/posts/' + articleID);

The only change required is to update the embed code in the posts.hbs file to use embed.js instead of embed.min.js.

To do this we replace nbb.src = nodeBBURL + '/plugins/nodebb-plugin-blog-comments/lib/embed.min.js'; with nbb.src = nodeBBURL + '/plugins/nodebb-plugin-blog-comments/lib/embed.js';

And that's it, you should now have NodeBB comments running on your Ghost v0.5.x blog.

peter

This sounds good. Can't wait to try this with wordpress once I have everything configured correctly.

esiao

@psychobunny
The plugin is not compatible with 0.5.3-dev
Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read property 'prepare' of undefined
In cause :

require(['forum/admin/settings'], function(Settings) {
	Settings.prepare();
});

Maybe it's because of the new admin panel, settings were moved ?

charles

@psychobunny

suggestions:

-option to only show comments with at least x number of upvote/favorite
-or way to filter comments and not show all of them in blog

fczuardi

I am using Ghost v0.5.8 and the required APIs that this plugin expects are not publicly accessible, my workaround was to monkey-patch the embed.js script in a very ugly hackish way, basically removing the ajax calls to the API and using a simple markdown with just the link to the post as the initial topic post on nodeBB, here is the gist:

nodebb-plugin-blog-comment monkey-patch

nodebb-plugin-blog-comment monkey-patch. GitHub Gist: instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

Gist (gist.github.com)

if (data.isAdmin) {
        //var adminXHR = newXHR();
        //adminXHR.open('GET', '/ghost/api/v0.1/posts/' + articleID);
        //adminXHR.onload = function() {
                //if (adminXHR.status >= 200 && adminXHR.status < 400) {
                        //var articleData = JSON.parse(adminXHR.responseText),
                                //markdown = articleData.markdown.split('\n\n').slice(0,2).join('\n\n') + '\n\n**Click [here]('+articlePath+') to see the fu$
    var markdown = '\n\n**Click [here]('+articlePath+') to see the full blog post**';
    var title = $('.post-title').text();
    document.getElementById('nodebb-content-markdown').value = markdown;
    document.getElementById('nodebb-content-title').value = title;
                        //document.getElementById('nodebb-content-title').value = articleData.title;
                //} else {
                        //nodebbDiv.innerHTML = 'Welcome ' + data.user.username + ', <a href="/ghost">sign in to Ghost</a> to enable the publish button.</a>$
                //}
        //}
        //adminXHR.send();
}

The file lives under nodebb/node_modules/nodebb-plugin-blog-comments/public/lib/embed.js

I've also made a blog post in Portuguese about how to install NodeBB and this plugin to be the comments system of a Ghost blog.

The solution is not clean, you have to go through all your posts and click the green button to make the initial topics on nodeBB, displaying an error json in the browser (but the thread is created anyways) and nodeBB will crash almost every time you create the new topics, but all this hassle is hopefully one-time-per-post only, so it is something I can live with for now.

I suggest people waiting for the clean solution to subscribe to the Ghost bug https://github.com/TryGhost/Ghost/issues/4181 and the nodebb-plugin-blog-comments bug https://github.com/psychobunny/nodebb-plugin-blog-comments/issues/17 to track the updates, or even beter, to submit a nice pull request to this plugin.

Eva Raposo

Which is the last compatible version from ghost that can manage the plugin?

fuzzmz

This post is deleted!

psychobunny

I've just released v0.3.0 of this plugin:

Fixed quite a few server crashes (especially when publishing)
Compatible with NodeBB 0.6x+ and Ghost 0.5.10
Added tags support for Ghost

EDIT: Updated OP

Charly86

@psychobunny
I've recently upgraded to NodeBB V0.8.0 and I encounter a wordpress comment plugins problem.
When I'm on wordpress, I still can view comments and respond to them, no problem, but when I created a new blog entry and wanted to create the entry on nodeBB but when I click on the button "Publish This Article to NodeBB" I got
{"error":"unable to post topic"} in browser return page
Do you think this can come from V0.8.0 update ?
thanks for your help

psychobunny

Can you post the error on nodebb server?

Charly86

@psychobunny
I launched ./nodebb dev but once launched it does not give me any error as soon as I click on publish button in wordpress

I put the full trace in case (and yes once started I clicked to publish ;-))

NodeBB v0.8.0 Copyright (C) 2013-2014 NodeBB Inc.
This program comes with ABSOLUTELY NO WARRANTY.
This is free software, and you are welcome to redistribute it under certain conditions.
For the full license, please visit: http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/gpl.html

Clustering enabled: Spinning up 1 process(es).

2/9 13:11 [11619] - info: Time: Wed Sep 02 2015 13:11:29 GMT+0200 (CEST)
2/9 13:11 [11619] - info: Initializing NodeBB v0.8.0
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: * using configuration stored in: /usr/local/share/nodebb/config.json
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: * using redis store at 127.0.0.1:6379
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: * using themes stored in: /usr/local/share/nodebb/node_modules
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: Checking dependencies for outdated modules
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [notifications.init] Registering jobs.
2/9 13:11 [11619] - info: [themes] Using theme nodebb-theme-persona
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Initializing plugins system
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 less file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-composer-default
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 10 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-composer-default
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-composer-default
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 less file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-markdown
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 2 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-markdown
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-markdown
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 less file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-mentions
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-mentions
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-mentions
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 css file(s) for plugin nodebb-widget-essentials
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-widget-essentials
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-rewards-essentials
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-rewards-essentials
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-soundpack-default
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-google-analytics
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-google-analytics
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-emailer-ssl-smtp
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-blog-comments
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-blog-comments
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-dbsearch
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 less file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-custom-pages
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-custom-pages
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-custom-pages
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-gravatar-extended
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 less file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-spam-be-gone
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-spam-be-gone
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-spam-be-gone
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-sso-github
2/9 13:11 [11619] - warn: [plugins/nodebb-plugin-sso-google] Hook `filter:user.delete` is deprecated, please use an alternative
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-sso-google
2/9 13:11 [11619] - warn: [plugins/nodebb-plugin-sso-facebook] Hook `filter:user.delete` is deprecated, please use an alternative
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 1 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-plugin-sso-facebook
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-sso-facebook
2/9 13:11 [11619] - warn: [plugins/nodebb-plugin-sso-twitter] Hook `filter:user.delete` is deprecated, please use an alternative
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-plugin-sso-twitter
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Found 4 js file(s) for plugin nodebb-theme-persona
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] Loaded plugin: nodebb-theme-persona

2/9 13:11 [11619] - warn: [plugins/load] The following plugins may not be compatible with your version of NodeBB. This may cause unintended behaviour or crashing. In the event of an unresponsive NodeBB caused by this plugin, run `./nodebb reset -p PLUGINNAME` to disable it.
  * nodebb-plugin-emailer-ssl-smtp
  * nodebb-plugin-blog-comments
  * nodebb-plugin-custom-pages
  * nodebb-plugin-gravatar-extended
  * nodebb-plugin-spam-be-gone

2/9 13:11 [11619] - info: [plugins] Plugins OK
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [meta/css] Minifying LESS/CSS
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [sounds] Sounds OK
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [meta/templates] Compiling templates
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [meta/js] Minification complete
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [meta/js] Client-side minfile committed to disk.
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [meta/templates] Successfully compiled templates.
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [meta/css] admin.css committed to disk.
2/9 13:11 [11619] - info: NodeBB Ready
2/9 13:11 [11619] - info: Enabling 'trust proxy'
2/9 13:11 [11619] - info: NodeBB is now listening on: 0.0.0.0:4567
2/9 13:11 [11619] - info: [plugins/spam-be-gone] Settings loaded
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [hotswap] Router with id `plugins` replaced successfully
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [plugins] All plugins reloaded and rerouted
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [meta/css] stylesheet.css committed to disk.
2/9 13:11 [11619] - verbose: [hotswap] Router with id `auth` replaced successfully

the browser windows is
upload-73763b2f-4c16-4ced-abcf-634420a10399

hope this help

Charly86

@psychobunny

Anyway, as a temp solution, I digged into the code but was unable to find what I needed, so maybe you can help me.
I wanted to try this (sure it should works)

I Create a new post on my nodebb forum and I get the database postID
I create a new Blog article on my wordpress forum and get ArticleID

Where do I put the link between both (I can do it manually inserting value in database), I think I just need to put NodeBB postID in wordpress database (near it's ArticleID), but I didn't found where. Any ideas ?

oH, just to let you know, my wordpress blog and my nodebb community are hosted on same VM (not same fqdn)

Thks

Charly86

@psychobunny
Oh, got a workaround, I really need to sleep more than 4 hours a night, the table was in front of my eyes it's in nodeBB database table blog-comments, just needed to add into this a new entry with key='blog post ID' and value='NodeBB topic ID'

In Wordpress database I get the post ID going to admin panel/posts then leaving the mouse on post link and looking the link in browser status bar
upload-28339102-d25e-4acc-9395-389462a50644
or with this mysql query on wordpress database to list them all

SELECT  post_date, ID, post_title, guid, post_status, post_type  FROM wp_posts
WHERE post_parent=0
ORDER BY `post_date` DESC

To find the NodeBB topic number into NodeBB, just create a topic then in Forum then find the post in the forum and leave the mouse on post link and looking the link in browser status bar
upload-8488d86c-ddb0-4be6-8d6a-adcbb5504c18

I've done it with Redis Desktop Mananager
upload-2cb3f355-4511-43b4-a1de-9f4aaa5c08bf

In case it can help

overlawled

Experiencing this issue on Wordpress as well.