@evan that's a reaction to the 'many people say X, but i think that's unlikely, they must all be [fallacy]'.
I'm not suggesting large groups must be right, but it sounds like the "you are not the user" fallacy?
It seems to me, you post these questions to learn more about how other people function. To then write that you dismiss a big group, seems weird.
But then, I hardly post, hardly respond to posts, so your engagement must be orders of magnitude different. That changes things too I guess